Marco's New York Italian (Sheffield)

Marco's New York Italian (Sheffield)

  • Italian

This restaurant is no longer open

But don’t worry, you can always try restaurants and offers nearby on this page!

Still feeling nostalgic? Why not read the old reviews

We say…

Marco’s New York Italian is an exquisite new restaurant in Sheffield city centre. Owned by Marco Pierre White, the menu takes inspiration from his Italian heritage and combines this with contemporary American cooking. It can be located next door to the Hampton by Hilton, making it perfect for visitors to Sheffield as well as its loyal local following.

The spacious interior of the restaurant welcomes all with its comfortable furnishings, gorgeous leather and cream décor. The dining room features tables of all sizes, from large rounded seating for parties and cosy intimate tables for a romantic evening. The venue sits right amongst the action on West Bar Green, making it easily accessible to and from Sheffield’s copious shops, theatre venues, and nightlife.

Crafted by Marco Pierre White himself, the menu presents a fresh new take on his trademark cooking style. Using the best local produce and a team of expertly trained chefs, guests are treated to an exciting array of American-Italian dishes. The a la carte menu showcases premium steaks, aromatic pizzas, New York burgers, gorgeous seafood, tasty pastas & risottos, and crispy salads. The dessert menu is packed with tons of tasty treats to top off the experience!

For a stylish and affordable dining experience, choose Marco’s New York Italian in Sheffield as your next destination. Whether you’re on your lunch break or you’re planning an extravagant night out, Marco’s caters to all!


Review summary

8.7 based on 26 reviews
  • Food
  • Value
  • Ambiance
  • Service

Reviews (26)

  • Neil Power

    Overall:

    The meal was excellent, nice environment, friendly staff, will definitely be returning. All three of us enjoyed our meal

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Anne Hunt

    Overall:

    Lovely food and fantastic staff. Good service from all. It’s a shame there wasn’t a better atmosphere as the restaurant was almost empty.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • karen wragg

    Overall:

    Ordered the festive lunch which comprised of soup then turkey dinner then Eton mess. The soup was ok nothing special and very watery. The turkey was not what I expected, it was like prepacked meat, disappointing really. The Eton mess was lovely.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Pam Morgan

    Overall:

    The whole experience was excellent, the staff were exceptional, altogether a relaxing and enjoyable afternoon.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Steve Hunter

    Overall:

    Booking through Godine worked faultlessly. Restaurant was lovely, decor and ambience. Service was friendly, efficient but unrushed, exactly right. Food was excellent but there could be more vegetarian options on the menu. Lunch menu very reasonable, even cheap. Will return and can definitely recommend.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Trevor Chetwynd

    Overall:

    Excellent early bird menu. Staff very good.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • stephen longmore

    Overall:

    The meal was ok we didn't realise that this was also a hotel. That was a disappointment with the name Marcos you except a little more. We will not be returning.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Cheryl jallow

    Overall:

    I and my sister had afternoon tea it was very nice, the staff were lovely very friendly and accommodating. Our whole experience was lovely and we fully enjoyed it.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Lisa Camm

    Overall:

    Bit disappointed to be honest as I was expecting more of the Manhattan till Midnight. I thought everyone was expected to arrive at 7pm & was noir expecting the Al la Carte menu which we ended up having. The place was half empty & noir much atmosphere. Solo singer sang modern songs in a "jazz" style. Staff were attentive but didn't appreciate being called "my loves" by a girl young enough to be my daughter. We ended up leaving after our meal & going to Triplets Wine Bar where there was an American jazz singer & amazing band. Now that's how you do a jazz night

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Oliver Tupling

    Overall:

    It’s the 3rd time we have been here and every time everything is just spot on. The staff are friendly but not overbearing, they ask you once if everything is ok then leave you to enjoy the amazing variety of food. Seeing the chefs working do hard cooking the food is a great touch. So clean and tidy. Everyone needs to try this place.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Oliver Tupling

    Overall:

    It’s the 3rd time we have been here and every time everything is just spot on. The staff are friendly but not overbearing, they ask you once if everything is ok then leave you to enjoy the amazing variety of food. Seeing the chefs working do hard cooking the food is a great touch. So clean and tidy. Everyone needs to try this place.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Naomi Carr

    Overall:

    Everything was great but plates were left on the table for a while before someone came to clear them.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Mollie Gunn

    Overall:

    I thought the atmosphere was great and loved the food.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Adrian Bodsworth

    Overall:

    Love food and great service. Food isn't cheap but is lovely quality. Would thoroughly recommend

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Hilary Mizler

    Overall:

    A bit disappointing I'm afraid. The food was very 'average' and soon went cold as the temperature in the building was decidedly cool. Even the singer who was fabulous kept putting her coat on between sets! The cocktails were gorgeous and I can't fault the service but the food was not up to expectations and the menu was surprisingly basic.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Stuart Ravenscroft

    Overall:

    Excellent food and service, enjoyable surroundings, had a great afternoon. Will definitely go again.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Dawn Ford

    Overall:

    Fantastic food, service and restaurant. I would recommend this restaurant to any one. Couples, families and parties. The service was efficient, friendly and welcoming. I will definitely go back and tell my friends about it.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Susan Fuller

    Overall:

    The staff made every effort to make the night a fantastic experience. Manager Katy can't be thanked enough for being so accommodating and made my wife's birthday so special. Food was terrific and excellent value. Definitely will going back.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Catherine Eccersley

    Overall:

    Surprisingly quiet for a Sunday lunch at Marco's so lacked a bit of atmosphere but that didn't detract from the gorgeous food and attentive service. Roast beef, and gammon and egg choices were perfectly cooked. Puds delicious too.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Lynn Taylor

    Overall:

    The overall meal at marco's was excellent

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Philip Rees

    Overall:

    Not sure how long Marco's New York Italian restaurant has been open in Sheffield, but it wasn't very busy at lunchtime on Valentine's Day. We were attracted by the special menu compiled for the day, but had to ask for it on arrival. It seems this was aimed at an evening audience, rather than lunchtime guests, but we were allowed to order from it and the food was good. We ordered starter dishes of scallops and pigeon breast, and duck and a crab linguine as our main courses. The main courses were substantial for us (short 'n' plump people) and the quality was very good, but not a 'knockout'. It wasn't a meal to inspire us to call or text our friends saying, "You must try this.." There also a children's menu and colouring pencils etc, to keep our eight year old entertained - so definitely child-friendly. The service was very good, but it was far from busy, so it's difficult to say how it would stand-up to a full house. When we asked for the bill a 10% service charge had been applied. Not something I like. I am always happy to tip good service, but I prefer it if I can choose to do so. Marco's is certainly an addition to our list of quality places to eat, and we hope it is successful.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Joe Holmes

    Overall:

    Brilliant meal and atmosphere at Marco's New York Italian.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Lynne Nelsom

    Overall:

    Excellent service and the food was wonderful.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Annie Charlton

    Overall:

    We visited Marco's for our departmental Christmas lunch. The venue was easy to find and parking was available for a reasonable price at the hotel next door. The service was good, staff were very attentive. We had a slight issue with a gravy spillage on a couple of the guests but we were suitably recompensed by the manager, with free drinks. Accidents do happen. The food was really nice, I couldn't fault it and my colleagues were much of the same opinion. All dietary requirements and associated allergy issues were dealt with wonderfully. One slight downside bearing in mind the occasion - there were no Christmas crackers! So we had to make up our own rubbish jokes instead :)

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Antonia Boothman

    Overall:

    The meal at Marco's New York Italian was delicious we really enjoyed it, very prompt service and the staff where very accommodating, 5 star!

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service
  • Wendy Steele

    Overall:

    Had a brilliant night here at Marco's New York Italian and would highly recommend it. Good food and value for money, simply a great night.

    Food
    Value
    Ambiance
    Service

Top Ranked Restaurants

View all